Observations Every Business Should Review Before Filing GSTR-9 and GSTR-9C - Refund Claims: The Audit Does Not End When Money Reaches the Bank
“A refund may be sanctioned today and still be questioned when the underlying credit is audited.”
A sanctioned GST refund can still be examined during a later departmental audit.
The audit issue
Refunds of unutilised ITC, tax paid on exports or other eligible amounts are based on specific statutory conditions and formulae. Exposure arises from ineligible ITC in the refund pool, incorrect turnover, non-realisation of export proceeds where relevant, mismatch with shipping or foreign-remittance records, double benefits, incorrect adjusted total turnover or failure to debit and restore electronic ledgers properly.
Legal framework
Section 54 of the CGST Act and Rules 89 to 97 govern refund claims and processing. Section 16 of the IGST Act governs zero-rated supplies. LUT or bond compliance under Rule 96A, export conditions, documentary requirements and the formula applicable to the refund category must be tested for the relevant claim period.
What the officer will examine
An auditor reconstructs the refund from invoices upward. Expect comparison of RFD forms, GSTR-1, GSTR-3B, shipping bills, export general manifest status, foreign inward remittance or BRC/FIRC evidence, LUT, purchase register, GSTR-2B and electronic credit ledger. The officer may recalculate net ITC and turnover and identify credits already used elsewhere or later reversed.
What to correct before GSTR-9 and GSTR-9C
Before GSTR-9/9C, reconcile every refund application, sanction, rejection, withholding and re-credit order with books and electronic ledgers. Maintain claim-period workings at invoice level. Remove blocked, unmatched or non-business credits from the refund base and verify export turnover against customs and banking evidence. Explain why refund turnover differs from financial-statement revenue due to timing or formula rules. Track post-sanction events such as export-proceeds realisation.
Closing takeaway
A refund order is not a substitute for a permanent evidence file. The best time to health-check a claim is while documents and transaction owners are still available,not years later when an audit asks you to rebuild the formula.
Practical audit scenario
Suppose a refund formula includes Rs. 25 lakh of ITC, but a later annual review identifies Rs. 3 lakh as blocked or attributable outside the claim period. The fact that the refund was sanctioned does not make that component permanently immune from verification. Reconstruct the claim with the same invoice population, turnover definitions and electronic-ledger movements used at filing. Also track rejected amounts and re-credits so they are not reclaimed twice. Exporters should link invoice, shipping, LUT and realisation evidence in one index instead of maintaining disconnected folders.
The safest approach is to identify and document the issue before the annual return is filed. Once an audit communication is issued, correction options may narrow and every explanation must be supported by records. The review should therefore record the factual position, legal conclusion, amount involved, return impact, corrective action, owner and supporting documents. Material positions should be approved, while immaterial differences should still be catalogued so repeated small errors do not become a pattern across tax periods. This converts a year-end reconciliation into a defensible audit file.
Before finalising your annual return, consider an independent GST reconciliation and health check focused on the records an audit officer is most likely to test.
Essential Checks Before You File GSTR-9 & 9C : Part 12
This is Part 12 of our 15-part series uncovering critical GST checks every business should complete before filing GSTR-9 and GSTR-9C or facing a departmental audit. Stay tuned for the next post.
Disclaimer : This article is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal or professional advice. Taxpayers should consult their tax advisor based on the facts of their specific case before taking any action.

