
Observations Every Business Should Review Before Filing GSTR-9 and GSTR-9C-Stock Transfers and Related-Party Supplies: No Consideration Does Not Always Mean No GST
“GST follows supplies between registrations even when no money moves between them.”
GST can apply even when no customer invoice and no money movement exist.
The audit issue
Supplies between distinct persons,such as separate GST registrations under the same PAN,and specified related-person transactions may be taxable under Schedule I even without consideration. Businesses often record branch transfers only through inventory journals, or allocate central expenses without examining cross-charge or input service distribution requirements. Free supplies to related parties and head-office support are frequent audit themes.
Legal framework
Section 7 read with Schedule I treats specified transactions as supplies without consideration. Section 25(4) and 25(5) define registrations as distinct persons. Section 15 and Rule 28 govern valuation. The input service distributor provisions and their effective requirements should be reviewed for common third-party input services distributed across registrations.
What the officer will examine
Officers compare stock-transfer challans, e-way bills, branch ledgers, expense allocations, employee locations, fixed assets and registration-wise profitability. They ask whether goods or services moved between GSTINs, whether invoices were raised, how value was determined and whether the recipient was eligible for full ITC. Head-office contracts benefiting multiple states are traced to the registration that claimed the original credit.
What to correct before GSTR-9 and GSTR-9C
For GSTR-9/9C, reconcile inter-branch inventory and service allocations across all GSTINs. Map shared functions,finance, HR, IT, management, branding and procurement,to beneficiaries. Confirm whether ISD or cross-charge treatment applies to each stream under the law for the relevant year. Retain valuation workings and recipient ITC status. Eliminate mismatches symmetrically: one GSTIN’s outward supply should correspond with the other GSTIN’s inward record.
Closing takeaway
Consolidated financial statements can hide registration-level supplies. GST does not. A PAN-wide annual review is essential where the business operates in more than one state or through more than one registration.
Practical audit scenario
A head office in Gujarat pays for enterprise software used by teams in four states and claims the entire ITC in Gujarat. Separately, head-office employees provide finance and HR support across registrations without any allocation analysis. These are different transaction streams and may require different treatment under the rules applicable to the year. The annual review should identify the contracting GSTIN, actual beneficiaries, nature of third-party service and internal supply, valuation approach and recipient credit position. A consolidated P&L cannot substitute for this registration-wise evidence.
The safest approach is to identify and document the issue before the annual return is filed. Once an audit communication is issued, correction options may narrow and every explanation must be supported by records. The review should therefore record the factual position, legal conclusion, amount involved, return impact, corrective action, owner and supporting documents. Material positions should be approved, while immaterial differences should still be catalogued so repeated small errors do not become a pattern across tax periods. This converts a year-end reconciliation into a defensible audit file.
Before finalising your annual return, consider an independent GST reconciliation and health check focused on the records an audit officer is most likely to test.
Essential Checks Before You File GSTR-9 & 9C : Part 11
This is Part 11 of our 15-part series uncovering critical GST checks every business should complete before filing GSTR-9 and GSTR-9C or facing a departmental audit. Stay tuned for the next post.
Disclaimer : This article is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal or professional advice. Taxpayers should consult their tax advisor based on the facts of their specific case before taking any action.

